Clean coal may be coming to New Jersey — a Massachussets firm wants to build a $5 billion, 500-megawatt electrical generating facility that would capture emissions, pump them a hundred miles and store them under the Atlantic Ocean.
If approved and built, it would be the first plant of its kind and would move us in a new energy direction, say advocates. It would allow us to continue using coal — the cheapest energy source — without its polluting effect, they say.
But there is a flaw in the reasoning. Finding a way to limit or eliminate the emmissions from energy sources seems a positive step, until it is made clear that there are other environmental problems with coal and other fossil fuels.
Even if the sequestration process works flawlessly, we’re still left seeking energy sources that require us to disturb large amounts of land — to find the coal and to create the piping infrastructure that would allow us to bury it.
I think Jeff Tittel, president of the New Jersey Sierra Club is correct:
“Coal is like heroin — cheap, plentiful and addictive, but very dangerous and to get it they take down mountains along with square-miles of trees, adding to the carbon output and environmental damage.”
Rather than find ways to make bad fuels less bad, we need to reduce our energy consumption — more efficient homes, cars, buildings — and find ways to make truly renewable sources like wind and solar cheaper.
There is no such thing as clean coal, coal is dirty from beginning to end use. There are 50 year old coal mines in Pennsylvania that are still burning. The coal mines under Centralia, PA, have been burning for more than 40 years and the town had to eventually be evacuated. Strip mining and mountain top mining are incredibly destructive to the environment. They devastate the landscape and pollute the air, soil, neighboring rivers, streams, lakes and ponds. In January, a coal sludge waste pond at a coal-burning power plant in northeast Alabama ruptured and a dike burst at a plant near Kingston, Tenn. on Dec. 22, releasing more than 1 billion gallons of toxic-laden coal fly ash slurry into a neighborhood. There are more than 1400 such coal sludge waste ponds in the country.Germany and Spain are not only moving away from all fossil fuels but also away from nuclear power. They have committed to the use of renewable energy such as solar, wind and geothermal.