Dispatches is about a Beatles-inspired performance I watched over the weekend and the failure of American culture to respect its cultural past.
Tag: music
Rock hall in a New York state of mind
A New York branch of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame? Looks that way.
The Times piece doesn’t mention it, but the final choice was between NY and Cleveland, where the hall landed. A New York satellite would be a nice addition — I’d suggest wings devoted to Lou Reed, Paul Simon, Billy Joel, Bruce Springsteen, Bob Dylan, the early folk revival, New York’s important punk/new wave scene of the ’70s (Television, New York Dolls, Ramones, Richard Hell, Patti Smith, etc.), early Manhattan hip-hop (Grandmaster Flash, breakdancing, etc.)and its outborough offshoots, doo-wop, the Brill Building, Ed Sullivan, Shea Stadium and the Garden, as well as New Jersey wing (lots of Bruce, a lock of Bon Jovi’s hair, some Southside stuff, Lauren Hill and Queen Latifah, etc.).
I’ll have to make a trip.
Tuesday Top Ten: Opening acts
Last week’s stellar performance by Elvis Costello opening for The Police got me thinking about opening acts I’ve seen over the years. So, today’s Top Ten is a double list — the 10 best and the five worst.
Best opening acts:
- Elvis Costello (for The Police, 2008)– as I said, a stellar performance that was way too short.
- Lucinda Williams (for John Mellencamp, 2008) — another opener that was way too short. Like EC, Lucinda is not your traditional tour support.
- The Specials (for The Police, 1981) — a thrilling and chilling set that included an eery “Ghost Town.”
- Charlie Louvin (for Lucinda Williams, 2007) — even my wife was impressed by the country legend.
- The Smithereens (for Lou Reed, 1986) — a loud and rowdy set.
- Willie Nile (for Southside Johnny and the Asbury Jukes, 1980) — better than act two (Hall and Oates — see below)
- Joe Ely (for Tom Petty, 1981) — country and rockabilly cool.
- The Go-Gos (for The Police, 1981) — just plain fun.
- Joan Jett (for The Police, 1983) — a raucous set.
- The Romantics (for Gram Parker, 1982) — so good, I went to see them headline a week or so later in Philly.
Honorable mention: The Pretenders (for the Rolling Stones, 2002) — deserved better than an indifferent crowd; George Thorogood (for the Rolling Stones, 1981) — a good match for the greatest rock ‘n’ roll band in history; Northern State (for Cake, 2002) — imagine the Beastie Boys as women; Holly and the Italians (for The Ramones, 1981) — great stuff; Sloan (for Jet, 2001) — quite impressive; Heart (The Eagles, 1980) — hot show; The Greg Kihn Band (for The Cars, 1979) — may have been better than the rather static headliners.
Worst:
- Joe Marino and Mahogany Rush (for Kansas, 1978) — overall one of the worst concerts I’ve been to.
- Henry Paul Band (for Styx, 1980) — see preceding comment.
- Journey (for the Rolling Stones, 1981) — for some reason, Steve Perry thought it would be a smart move to thank the crowd for making the band the most popular rock band in America. The crowd responded with a well-deserved round of silence. Blecch.
- Little River Band — I saw them open for two different bands, Jimmy Buffett in 1977 and The Eagles in 1980, and they were as light and unnecessary as you might expect.
- Hall and Oates (for Southside Johnny and the Asbury Jukes, 1980) — this is an unfortunate one, because I like their early stuff and had seem them put on a good show in 1978.
Cheese it! The copsThoughts on The Police at PNC
I have been meaning since getting home Sunday night to offer thoughts on what I felt to be a remarkable reunion show by one of my all-time favorite bands, The Police. Here it is Friday, however, and still no review — as my wife pointed out yesterday.
But then I read this review of last night’s tour closer at Madison Square Garden — a show that sounded quite similar to the one I attended, right down to the cartoon image of Porky Pig on the video screen after the final encore.
I was skeptical of the reunion tour when I first learned that they would be hitting the road, interested in getting tickets, but wary because Sting’s solo career has made it easy to forget just how powerful a band The Police were in their prime.
I saw them for the first time in 1981, when they played one of two U.S. shows during a break from recording Ghost in the Machine. The festival show — which also featured the Coasters, Oingo Boingo, the Go-Gos and The Specials — offered previews of the unfinished album (I still remember the band unveiling “Demolition Man,” which fairly exploded from the stage.
Their 1983 show at Shea was just as good. And then they broke up, their clashing egos leading then to disband at the height of the powers.
But that doesn’t really say anything about Sunday’s show in Holmdel (Asbury Park Press review here).
First, the band still rocks. The 18-song set (they merged “Voices Inside My Head” with “When the World is Running Down You Make the Best of What’s Still Around”) offered a compendium of greatest hits, most of them played at a break-neck pace that kept the packed house standing for nearly the entire show.
Second, Stuart Copeland is one of the great rock drummers (if not the greatest) and Andy Summers belongs on any short list of guitar greats. I’ve been listening to the band since high school, since the release of Outlandos D’Amor, and have witnessed their transformation from ska/punk through what I would call reggae/art rock to a sound that defies easy categorization. The musicianship — and this includes Sting’s bass playing — makes this transformation seem natural, especially when recontextualized in concert and removed from a chronological setting.
Third, Sting can still sing rock and roll. (He really should do a lot more of it, rather than that weak junk he has spent much of his solo career playing.)
Elvis Costello opened with a dozen-song set that set the bar incredibly high. (I should say up front that I probably like EC more than The Police, though that’s like choosing between Ben and Jerry’s and Edy’s — that’s to say that both are great.)
Elvis played a lot from his latest, Momofuku, one of the best records of his career (he called it a record, as opposed to “one of those little silver things you throw at your brother”), with old material mixed in.
The highlight of the set, however, was “Alison,” on which he was joined by Sting.
After watching the set, I updated by Facebook page by writing that I thought that if the Police were to be as good as EC, we were “in for one special night.”
We were.
Set lists:
Elvis Costello
- “Stella Hurts”
- “Pump It Up”
- “Either Side of the Same Town”
- “Every Day I Write the Book”
- “American Gangster Time”
- “(I Don’t Want to Go to) Chelsea”
- “45”
- “Flutter and Wow”
- “Turpentine”
- “Watching the Detectives”
- “Alison” w/Sting
- “(What’s So Funny ’bout) Peace, Love and Understanding?”
The Police
- “Message In A Bottle”
- “Walking On The Moon”
- “Demolition Man”
- “Voices Inside My Head”
- “When The World Is Running Down, You Make The Best Of What’s Still Around”
- “Don’t Stand So Close To Me”
- “Driven To Tears”
- “Hole In My Life”
- “Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic”
- “Wrapped Around Your Finger”
- “De Do Do Do, De Da Da Da”
- “Invisible Sun”
- “Can’t Stand Losing You”
- *”Roxanne”
- *”King Of Pain”
- *”So Lonely”
- *”Every Breath You Take”
- **”Next to You”
* First encore
** Second encore
Speaking of music: Bruce and R.E.M.
I mentioned in my running post that I was listening to some iTunes exclusives — three, in fact, but two that are worth noting:

Bruce Springsteen, Magic Tour Highlights: Four songs w/accompanying videos and proceeds going to the Danny Federici Melanoma Fund.
Consider the track listing:
1. “Always A Friend” (performed with Alejandro Escovedo)
Recording Date: 04/14/2008 (Houston, Texas)
2. “The Ghost of Tom Joad” (performed with Tom Morello)
Recording Date: 04/07/2008 (Anaheim, California)
3. “Turn Turn Turn” (performed with Roger McGuinn)Recording Date:
04/23/2008 (Orlando, Florida)
4. “4th Of July, Asbury Park (Sandy)” (Danny Federici’s final
performancewith the E Street Band)
Recording Date: 03/20/2008 (Indianapolis, Indiana)
The $7.99 I spent on iTunes would have been worth it for any of the songs, but all four are gems. Escovedo, for readers who do not know, is one of the great Texas country-rock songwriters and one of my favorites from what is sometimes called the alt-country or Americana movement. Bruce and Alejandro let it all hang out and have a great time on the tune.
R.E.M., Live from London: a nine-song set recorded at the Apple iTunes Store in London includes tracks from Accelerate and several old chestnuts (“West of the Fields” and “Auctioneer” are real surprises, along with “Fall on Me” and “Man on the Moon”). Quite a great listen.
Also, check out the extended version of Accelerate (at Amazon, iTunes or elsewhere), which includes two torrid songs not on the CD (along with some live material): “Redhead Walking” and “Airliner” (a driving instrumental).
