The Mets have moved from being a scrappy, injury-depleted team to being perhaps the worst baseball team around — a team that lacks fire and does not seem to understand the basics of the baseball.
Players constantly flub pops because they’re making one-handed catches, regularly throw to the wrong base of past cut-off men, find themselves out of position and lose focus. This is not the way a team many expected to contend in the East (let alone possibly win it all) is supposed to play.
The question is, then, whose fault is it? Certainly the players bear responsibility, but the problems the team has been experiencing are ones that must be addressed by the manager. And that brings us to the point of this post: Should Jerry Manuel be fired? I’m not willing to say yes, at the moment, but we are fast approaching the time when the front office will have to answer that question.
Manuel seems well-suited to New York, has that easy-going manner and can handle the pressures of the media. But he has run this team for just over a year, presided over a season-ending collapse and is now toiling at three games below .500. The team is badly schooled and — this may be key — has suffered from some odd managerial decisions this year. Why pinch-hit for Daniel Murphy with Fernando Tatis? Why the attraction to Tatis at this point, given that he has become an automatic double-play?
I know you have to play the cards you’ve been dealt — Alex Cora has been in the league a long time but is not an everyday shortstop — but you still don’t bet the house when you have two of a kind.
Omar Minaya will make the decision — and also sits on the hot seat. There are some who view his tenure as a failure, his good moves marked only by the Mets having more money than most, but I disagree. He’s made some interesting pickups that have panned out and others that have not, but he needs to go out and get someone that can help address the team’s woeful lack of offense. It would be foolish to wait for players to return from the DL — that didn’t work last year with Pedro — because there are no guarantees.
Minaya, however, should not be the issue — at least not until the end of the season. The issue is Manuel and whether he can get this team to start using its head. If he can’t, they need to bring in someone else who can.