The votes are in and Jack Murtha is not. Well, he is not the majority leader, though he will head up an important committee overseeing the war.
What is striking about the coverage of this insider battle is how much ink is being invested and how the Beltway press has turned what essentially is a minor news story into a 24-hour yackfest.
The basic theme, as Glenn Greenwald points out in his Unclaimed Territory blog, is that the selection of Steny Hoyer as majority leader over Murtha is a major defeat for Nancy Pelosi and that the Democrats are badly divided. (There are rivalries, but aside from the recent rubber-stamp GOP, there always is.) But as Greenwald says, there is no evidence to suggest this and it seems nothing more than the kind of speculative nonsense that makes watching cable news such a surreal experience.
It is important to remember that the Beltway pundits are not journalist and bear no similarity to the people doing good work, digging up information that is important for the democracy. At best, they should be viewed as Vegas odds-makers who refuse to do any research.
The other issue is the general tenor of attacks on Pelosi, which are similar in their tone and substance to those made against Hillary Clinton — I actually saw the word “catfight” used. This is all about gender and nothing else.
The kind of behavior she is being criticized for is exactly the kind of behavior these same useless talking heads praise in male politicians.
And one last thing: Why is it, as Keith Olbermann said last night, that a knock-down dragout that resulted in the return of a compromised racist to the Senate GOP leadership is being painted as a comeback story, while a battle for the second-in-command slot among Congressional Democrats is the tsunami that will wipe Nancy Pelosi out of office.
As Eric Alterman would say, “what liberal media?”
It is important to remember what the November election was about — Iraq and the eroding middle class — and that elections for leadership positions are about insider influence and favors and that both of these men were badly flawed. The other leadership fights — in particular, the one between Jane Harman (wrong on the war, on eavesdropping and torture) and Alcee Hardee (ethically challenged) — will come down to the same political calculus.
Nancy Pelosi, ultiamtely, will be judged on what the Democrats accomplish under her leadership and these petty leadership fights — analagous, really, to the selection of team captain for a college football team or a fraternity or sorority president — will be long forgotten.
South Brunswick Post, The Cranbury Press
The Blog of South Brunswick