My list of top Knicks

Interesting column on the best Knick ever — got me thinking about how I would rank them (I go back only as far as the championship squads, so fans of Harry Gallatin, Richie Guerin and Dick McGuire take note).

So here goes:

  1. Willis Reed
  2. Walt Frazier
  3. Patrick Ewing
  4. Dave DeBusschere
  5. Earl Monroe
  6. Bernard King
  7. Bill Bradley
  8. Charles Oakley (his number should be retired and the organization knows it)
  9. Dick Barnett
  10. Jerry Lucas
  11. Jon Starks
  12. Mark Jackson
  13. Bill Cartwright
  14. Michael Ray Richardson
  15. Ray Williams

I know I’ve left some players off (Latrell Sprewell and Allan Houston??) but this seems to be a good start. Knick fans, what do you think?

South Brunswick Post, The Cranbury Press
The Blog of South Brunswick

The stakes

I’ve written about this before but it cannot hurt to re-emphasize just exactly what’s at stake tomorrow when we head into the voting booth — i.e., that tomorrow’s vote should be a referendum on President George W. Bush, Donald Rumsfeld, Iraq and the constitutional separation of powers. As The New York Times wrote on Sunday:

This election is indeed about George W. Bush — and the Congressional majority’s insistence on protecting him from the consequences of his mistakes and misdeeds. Mr. Bush lost the popular vote in 2000 and proceeded to govern as if he had an enormous mandate. After he actually beat his opponent in 2004, he announced he now had real political capital and intended to spend it. We have seen the results. It is frightening to contemplate the new excesses he could concoct if he woke up next Wednesday and found that his party had maintained its hold on the House and Senate.

I live in New Jersey, where the two sides have been waging a television war of attrition that seems designed to suppress the vote.

But it seems pretty clear to me that New Jersey voters should send Bob Menendez back to the Senate. Sen. Menendez, who spent a dozen years in the House of Representatives before being appointed by Gov. Jon Corzine in January to replace the new governor in the Senate, voted against the war authorization in 2003, when it was considered politically unpopular to do so, and has remained steadfast in his opposition to the disaster the president has created.

Just as importantly, he is a Democrat and the nation needs the Democrats to take over at least one house of Congress as the first step in a change of direction nationally. The nation can not afford to continue thumbing its nose at the international community and it literally cannot afford to subsidize the rich at the expense of the rest of us.

The Republican challenger, state Sen. Tom Kean Jr., has raised some valid questions about Sen. Menendez and the political culture of New Jersey. But he has ran a harshly negative campaign that left me wondering what kind of lines he would cross were he elected.

More significantly, he has failed to answer questions about his past stance on Social Securitprivatizationon and remains steadfast in support of the war (though he would toss Donald Rumsfeld overboard). And while he paints himself as a moderate, he is likely to side with his party’s leadership, leaving the same bunch of right-wingers in charge of tax, military and environmental policy — the same bunch that has made such a mess in the first place.

So while he may think of himself as an independent actor, the reality is that he cannot be — there cannot be independent actors in Washington these days.

So I’ll vote for Bob Menendez and hope the rest of the nation follows suit and boots the GOP from its majority status.

That said, I have my doubts that this will happen (even if Dick Morris and Eileen McGann say so). There are a lot of people who want to see the GOP dumped, but not their own GOP Congressman — plus there is the unfortunate tendency of national Democrats to turn strength to weakness. My fear is that the Democrats will come close, but fail to capture either House, and that it will be spun as a Democratic loss, giving the national media cause to minimize what the party actually may end up accomplishing.

So vote early and vote often. It is your patriotic duty.

South Brunswick Post, The Cranbury Press
The Blog of South Brunswick

Creating the right impression

Received a flier on card stock in the mail today from the local Democrats that had some familiar language:

Gambatese and Killmurray … are offering a vision of the future.

Both have worked hard and have been successfull …

They have acted and deserve credit …

We endorse them without any reservations.

The language is familiar, of course, because it is the same language we used in an editorial a week ago, but edited to maximize impact.

It is a pretty standard tactic — a number of years ago, the Republican candidates used a stray remark in a flier to make it seem as if we were endorsing them (this was back in 1991, when Roger Craig ran and won his first race for Township Committee; the add said we called him experienced, but failed to mention that we refused to endorse him even as we endorsed his running mate Jeff Siegel).

Another year, the GOP used critical comments from us about the Democrats in an flier (we were portrayed as a small thought bubble of some sort). And the Democrats have done the same over the years.

I offer this post not as direct criticism, but only to ensure that the full edit remains in play. So here is the portion quote, but unedited:

The incumbents have put together mixed, but generally positive, records in office and are offering a vision of the future. Both have worked hard and have been successful at preserving open space and plan to make smaller parcels in already developed areas a priority, something that should aid residents in the more congested sections of town.

While we have been critical of their approach to the township budget, in particular their use of surplus, we believe their focus on sharing services with neighboring communities could result in real cost savings for taxpayers.

Our chief criticism of Mayor Gambatese and Mr. Killmurray is that they too often have needed to be prodded into action — as with the township’s recently enacted rental-inspection rules and the push to preserve Van Dyke Farm on Davidsons Mill Road. The key, however, is that they have acted and deserve credit for doing so.

We endorse them without any reservations.

South Brunswick Post, The Cranbury Press
The Blog of South Brunswick

Menendez, the peace candidate

Katrina vanden Heuvel, The Nation’s editor, names 12 candidates for House and Senate in her blog who it calls peace candidates. Among them, Bob Menendez here in Joisey. Here is what she said:

Sen. Bob Menendez opposed the Iraq War from the start, back when most of his Democratic colleagues in the Senate failed to take a strong stand. Although Menendez angered many in the peace movement with his vote for the Military Commissions Act, he supports beginning troop withdrawal this year. He faces a tough opponent in Tom Kean, Jr., and is locked in a tight race.

South Brunswick Post, The Cranbury Press
The Blog of South Brunswick