Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band — released 40 years ago today — maybe the single most overrated album in rock history.
That may sound counter-intuitive and a bit heretical, but hear me out. I’m not downplaying the album’s quality — it is a groundbreaking work with an artistic vision that remains surprisingly alive (mostly).
It’s just that the album doesn’t live up to the hype. But then, really, nothing could.
Mythologized like no other album in rock history, credited with single-handedly altering the landscape, Sgt. Pepper’s has become rock music’s version of “The Wasteland” or Ulysses.
Artistically, it remains a powerful and important work, but it is not one that stands above all else, especially when placed within the context of its time, its contemporary musical landscape and The Beatles own remarkable canon.
Historical context: The album may be the definitive psychedic soundtrack, which is both its strength and primary weakness. Connected to the Summer of Love via its exploration of Indian ragas and massive, multitracked sound, it also is incredibly selfconscious and arty, almost to a fault.
But as so many critics, if not fans, have come to realize about the album, it fosters an illusion (delusion?) of peace and love (in its sound if not in its lyrics, which mostly are about malaise), reinforcing the clichés of hippiedom at a time when the darker elements of the sixties were slowly coming into view (the band catches this in “A Day In A Life”). Because of this, the record stands in many ways as a great fake, as Devin McKinney wrote in his find book Magic Circles: The Beatles in Dream and History (my review here).
Musical context: Sgt. Peppers was a groundbreaking record, but not in isolation. It was part of an amazing continuum of change that included records by The Beatles themselves (Rubber Soul and Revolver) , Dylan (the electric trio), the Byrds and particularly The Beach Boys.
Dylan, of course, expanded the genre’s lyrical possibilities, bringing the vocabulary of literary expressionism and surrealism to popular song while simultaneously expanding the boundaries of the blues form. Highway 61 Revisited with its organ assaults and explosive wall of music opened new frontiers, while The Beatles’ two records did the same for the pop side of the rock equation.
The Beatles’ records, in particular, had an amazing impact on Brian Wilson and The Beach Boys, who released Pet Sounds a full year before Sgt. Pepper’s came out. From All Music:
The group here reached a whole new level in terms of both composition and production, layering tracks upon tracks of vocals and instruments to create a richly symphonic sound. Conventional keyboards and guitars were combined with exotic touches of orchestrated strings, bicycle bells, buzzing organs, harpsichords, flutes, theremin, Hawaiian-sounding string instruments, Coca-Cola cans, barking dogs, and more.
The songs were great, perfectly structured, and Paul McCartney in particular has said he viewed it as a challenge. There would have been no Sgt. Pepper’s without Pet Sounds, but no Pet Sounds without Revolver and Rubber Soul, and perhaps no Revolver and Rubber Soul without Dylan and so on. The continuum.
(One other note on this: The Beatles and the Beach Boys did not pioneer the use of violins and other “nonrock” instruments on rock records. Buddy Holly used them way back in 1958 and 1959.)
The Beatles canon: I love Sgt. Pepper’s. I do, despite what this post might seem to imply. But I don’t think it is the best Beatle record recorded — not by a long shot. Each record has a lot to recommend it, of course, but I take the two 1965 records, Rubber Soul and Revolver, mostly because they show a brooding edge and complete unity, and because they are the bridge records taking the band from early lighter days into the slow dissolution that follows Sgt. Pepper’s.
They also contain the best songs, the tightest, most well-crafted and mature music the band was to make.
But that doesn’t diminish what Sgt. Pepper’s is: a remarkable and majestical record by the greatest band in the history of popular music.
South Brunswick Post, The Cranbury Press
The Blog of South Brunswick
The Cranbury Press Blog
E-mail me by clicking here
Hank Kalet 
Oi, achei teu blog pelo google tá bem interessante gostei desse post. Quando der dá uma passada pelo meu blog, é sobre camisetas personalizadas, mostra passo a passo como criar uma camiseta personalizada bem maneira. Até mais.